Cutting to the chase: what a retention curve taught us about the first minute of a movie
A feature film’s opening is designed for a room where nobody leaves. The audience has bought a ticket, found a seat and watched the lights go down. Logos, a slow title sequence, a long establishing shot: a theater gives all of it time to work.
A feed or a click online doesn’t work like that. When we put Vamps on YouTube, the retention curve showed us exactly where the theatrical opening had just stopped working for the online audience, and it was earlier than we expected.
The number that matters: thirty seconds
YouTube Studio reports a figure it calls Intro: the share of viewers still watching at the 30-second mark. For Vamps, it was 5%. Put another way, 9 in 10 people who pressed play were gone before the intro credits played.
The shape of the curve told the rest. As soon as the first scene, which was meant to entice and intrigue, was done, audience retention plummeted. The people who made it into the story mostly stayed. The problem wasn’t the film, but rather cutting to the chase.
Why the opening is harder online
Two things change when a film is watched on a platform instead of in a theater.
Commitment is not the same. A ticket is a decision made in advance. A click is a decision made in a second, and it gets made again in the first few seconds of playback.
Many viewers didn’t come looking for this film in particular. About half of the channel’s traffic arrives through suggested video: YouTube placing Vamps next to other noir that people are already watching. That’s the strongest signal the channel has, and it also means a large share of the audience meets the film cold. They clicked because the thumbnail and title promised noir and vampires. The first seconds have to keep that promise, quickly, or they click away looking for that fulfillment elsewhere.
A theatrical opening asks for patience in exchange for atmosphere. A viewer who arrived from a suggestion hasn’t agreed to that trade yet.
What we cut
And just like the old, Hollywood-inspired adage goes, we cut to the chase. For the online version, we had to cut the intro credits and the some of the stylized, animated sequence that gave some of the story background. We’re proud of those sequences, but they were just not working for online audiences.
The new version reaches the noir story 5 minutes earlier than before. It was a hard edit to make because of the value we put in the animation and the intro sequence creativity, but we trust audiences to appreciate the rest of the film and its story just the same—they can catch up without the background.
Three principles we’d apply to any trim like this:
- Move the credits if you can; if you don’t, then delete them. Titles and logos can move to the end. All depending on your contracts, of course.
- Open on the genre. The first image should tell a cold viewer what kind of film this is. For our case of noir, that’s shadows, a half-lit face, a narrator’s voice.
- Cut the doorway, not the story. The aim isn’t to restructure the film but to shorten the time before the captivating story starts.
What changed
With the change, watch rate climbed to 30% after the intro, when it was 5% in the past.
One caution for anyone running the same comparison: compare similar date ranges and the same traffic sources. A burst of suggested traffic changes the curve on its own, and it’s easy to credit the edit for what the algorithm did.
What it means for the next film
We now think of a finished film as needing two openings: one for the theater and one for the feed. Or, maybe, projects need to be natively thought of as for theaters or for content-mode online. The online version in the future will get its own opening, built for a viewer who can leave with one tap.
A retention curve is the closest a filmmaker gets to watching an audience in the dark when it comes to streaming online. It doesn’t tell you whether the film is good; rather, it tells you exactly where people stopped giving it a chance.